Fake Witches, Fake Books

In recent years, witchcraft has taken a bold step out of the shadows and into mainstream culture. Social media is flooded with influencers showcasing their “witchy” aesthetics—gorgeous altars adorned with twinkling crystals, perfectly arranged spell jars, and elaborate ritual setups that seem plucked straight out of a fairytale. 

Shops selling crystals and "magickal" products are cropping up on nearly every street corner, making the practice seem more accessible than ever before. But with this newfound visibility comes an unfortunate side effect: the rise of inauthenticity and commercialization in witchcraft.

The Business of Witchcraft

Witchcraft, a practice deeply rooted in personal empowerment, connection to nature, and ancient spiritual traditions, is now part of a booming industry. It's easy to be drawn in by the allure of trendy witchcraft products and shiny new books on spellcraft, but these often miss the mark. While there’s nothing inherently wrong with purchasing a pretty crystal or candle, true witchcraft is much more than a collection of aesthetically pleasing tools. 

At its core, witchcraft involves a personal journey—one steeped in intentionality, spiritual growth, and the passing down of wisdom through generations. Unfortunately, the true essence of the craft often gets overshadowed by the overwhelming presence of mass-produced items designed more for looks than for authentic magickal work.

The Profit-Driven Side of Witchcraft

As witchcraft has risen in popularity, an entire industry has emerged, driven more by profits than by a genuine connection to the craft. Social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok are full of influencers who promote "witchy" products—everything from pre-made spell jars and crystal sets to ritual kits and themed tarot decks. Many of these influencers are more focused on selling products and building their brand than on sharing real, deep knowledge about magick.

On platforms like Etsy, you’ll find endless pre-made spell jars, ritual kits, and magickal bundles being sold for a premium. While these items often look stunning, they frequently lack the personal intention and ritual preparation that’s essential to authentic magick. Worse still, many of these sellers don’t even practice witchcraft themselves—they’ve simply latched onto the trend to capitalize on its aesthetic appeal. The result is a marketplace overflowing with products that appear impressive but offer little in terms of spiritual depth or meaningful connection to the craft.

The Rise of Fake and Copied Books

The commercialization of witchcraft doesn’t stop at products—it’s also seeped into literature. As the interest in witchcraft has grown, so has the number of books flooding the market, claiming to offer beginners all the secrets they need to cast spells, tap into ancient wisdom, or connect with the natural world. But most of these books are little more than rehashed versions of older works or, in some cases, blatant plagiarized content. The problem? These books lack the depth, insight, and personal experience that comes from real practitioners.

The rise of self-publishing platforms has made it easier than ever for anyone to throw together a book, fill it with recycled content, and sell it as a “guide to witchcraft.” These books are poorly researched, offering only surface-level information that misleads readers who are genuinely trying to learn the craft. For new practitioners, picking up one of these books and finding nothing but generic advice and shallow explanations can be deeply frustrating.

The Harm to Real Authors

This flood of fake and mass-produced content has a significant impact on real authors who have dedicated their lives to the study and practice of witchcraft. For these individuals, writing about the craft isn’t just a hobby or a quick way to make a buck—it’s an extension of their spiritual journey. 

Creating a work on witchcraft involves years of personal experience, research, and deep introspection, often intertwining with the author's own growth as a practitioner. When their work is copied or buried beneath a pile of low-quality material, it robs them of not just recognition and sales, but the integrity and meaning behind their contributions.

For many genuine authors, having their hard work diluted by those who have no true connection to the magickal community isn’t just frustrating—it’s disheartening. It feels like a theft of their spiritual essence, as though the deep meaning behind their work has been trivialized. The rise of fake books and copied content makes it more difficult for authentic voices to be heard, with their insights drowned out by the sheer volume of shallow material flooding the market.

The Mysterious Case of Non-Existent Authors

To make matters worse, publishers have started creating entirely fake authors to sell more witchcraft books. Recognizing the profit potential in the witchcraft trend, some publishers have invented mystical-sounding personas like "Mystic Ravenmoon" or "Sorceress Nightshade" to entice readers into buying books written by these fictional authors. These names, paired with elaborate backstories, create the illusion of a wise and seasoned witch with deep knowledge of the craft. But these authors don’t exist—they’re simply marketing tools designed to boost sales.

These fictional personas often come with long, intricate histories that give readers the impression they’re learning from a real practitioner with years of experience. But the truth is, these books are ghostwritten or cobbled together from recycled content, offering little in the way of genuine magickal knowledge. Readers, unaware of the deception, purchase these books expecting to receive meaningful insights, only to be met with hollow, generic advice that lacks the spiritual depth and personal connection of authentic witchcraft.

Fictional Personas Dilute the Craft

The rise of fake witches and ghostwritten witchcraft books not only misleads readers, but it also dilutes the craft itself. Witchcraft is a deeply personal practice, requiring dedication, self-reflection, and a true connection to nature and the energies around us. When publishers and influencers create fake witches to sell products or books, they strip witchcraft of its authenticity, reducing it to little more than a passing trend.

Readers who turn to these fictional personas often end up with a shallow understanding of the craft, learning only surface-level information instead of the deep, transformative practices that come with years of study and experience. This watered-down version of witchcraft can leave genuine seekers feeling disconnected and disillusioned, unsure of where to turn for real spiritual guidance.

The Emotional Impact on Readers

For those genuinely seeking spiritual growth and empowerment through witchcraft, discovering that the author they trusted is a fictional creation can be devastating. Many people come to witchcraft hoping to find deeper meaning, wisdom, and personal transformation. When they realize that the person they believed was guiding them doesn’t even exist, it can feel like a betrayal.

This disillusionment is especially harmful for newcomers to the craft, who may struggle to distinguish between authentic voices and those created for profit. As the market becomes more saturated with fake witches and fictional personas, it becomes increasingly difficult to find genuine sources of information and guidance.

Supporting Real Authors and Practitioners

In a world where witchcraft is becoming increasingly commercialized, it is more important than ever to support real authors and practitioners. These individuals have spent years studying and practicing witchcraft, and their work often comes from a place of deep spiritual insight and personal experience. By purchasing books from authentic sources, attending workshops led by experienced practitioners, and engaging with real witchcraft communities, seekers can ensure that they are learning from those who truly understand the craft.

Supporting authentic voices helps preserve the integrity of witchcraft and ensures that future generations can access the rich, transformative traditions that have been passed down through centuries. It also helps counteract the rise of fake witches and mass-produced books, allowing genuine practitioners to share their wisdom without being drowned out by the noise of commercialization.

Avoiding the Noise

The commercialization of witchcraft has created a lot of noise, making it harder to find the real magick amid the trend-driven content. While there’s nothing wrong with buying a pretty crystal or following a witchy influencer, it’s important to dig deeper. True witchcraft requires more than just tools—it’s about knowledge, dedication, and a deep connection to the natural world and the energies around you.

By being discerning in where you get your information—whether through books, social media, or products—you can avoid falling into the trap of commercialized magick. The real journey of witchcraft is one of personal empowerment, spiritual growth, and connection, not something that can be packaged and sold.

The Impact on the Craft

The rise of fake witches, ghostwritten books, and mass-produced spells affects more than just individuals—it ripples through the entire witchcraft community. The deep traditions and spiritual practices that have been passed down through generations are at risk of being overshadowed by trend-driven content that prioritizes aesthetics and profit over substance. Witchcraft isn’t about the latest Instagram trend or a perfectly curated altar; it’s about working with ancient energies, connecting with nature, and engaging in a practice that requires real commitment.

True witchcraft is a lifelong journey that requires ongoing study, practice, and personal reflection. The commercialization of magick may be loud and distracting, but for those who are willing to look beyond the surface, the real magick is still there, waiting to be discovered by those who genuinely seek it.

In Conclusion: Authenticity Matters

In a world filled with fake witches, fictional personas, and mass-produced books, authenticity is more valuable than ever. By choosing carefully where you get your information, whether it’s from books, classes, or mentors, you can tap into the rich and diverse traditions of witchcraft and avoid the shallow commercialized aspects of modern magick.

Supporting genuine authors and practitioners helps preserve the deep, transformative traditions of witchcraft and ensures that future generations can continue to benefit from its wisdom. So, before you buy that pre-made spell jar or follow that trendy witchy account, take a moment to look beyond the aesthetics and consider the source—because the true power of witchcraft lies in its authenticity.